Managing Plug Load is the Next Challenge for Energy Efficient Buildings
Take a quick look at a typical office and you see machines like computers and copiers that are essential to operating a business. Then look at individual work spaces and note the task lights, cell phone chargers, and portable electric heaters under the desk. What these and many other everyday items have in common is that they plug directly into the building's electrical system. They constitute a building's plug load.
The actual plug load of a building depends on numerous factors and no two buildings are exactly alike. Estimates of the contribution of plug load to overall building energy usage vary widely. The U.S. Department of Energy estimates that plug load represents 26% of energy use in commercial offices. This is shown in the pie chart on the left.
As the pie chart in the center indicates, plug load as a percentage of total energy use can approach 50% when the HVAC and lighting – the largest users of energy – are reduced through efficient designs. According to David Kaneda, President of Integrated Design Associates (IDeAs) in San Jose, Cal., "Designs have become more efficient in lighting and HVAC. Now we're looking at how buildings actually use energy and we find that plug load is a higher and higher proportion."
As the middle chart demonstrates, improvements in lighting and HVAC efficiency have the effect of increasing plug load as a percentage of total building energy usage. Implementing a system that manages plug load can bring the energy use of a building back into proportion and save an additional 10% in energy use. This result is shown in the pie chart to the right.
What is plug load?
The simplest definition of plug load is: the amount of energy drawn by devices from an electrical outlet. This can be further divided into two general types of equipment: office equipment and miscellaneous equipment. Office equipment is all the equipment that is needed to actually conduct business, such as desktop computers, monitors, and copiers. Miscellaneous equipment covers items such as kitchen appliances, vending machines and water coolers in common areas and personal electronic devices that make workspaces feel more like home – desk lamps, radios, speakers, fans, and small heaters. Miscellaneous equipment also includes plug-in media equipment such as televisions and projectors. Yet another source of plug load – and one that is proliferating – is chargers for portable electronic devices.
Each of these devices draws power and contributes to plug load – sometimes even when they are switched off. Standby power is electricity used by appliances and equipment while they are switched off or not performing their primary function. That power is consumed by power supplies, circuits and sensors needed to receive a remote signal, keypads, and displays including status lights. While less than the typical 5% in residential buildings, standby power use in commercial buildings is still a significant contributor to plug load.
Plug load equipment also generates heat and, as such, require additional cooling capacity. However, the cooling demand of plug-in equipment is difficult to predict. "This area needs more study," says Kaneda. "But there is an impact on total building energy consumption beyond the plug load itself. More plug load means more heat generated means more air conditioning required."
Traditionally design teams have considered plug loads to be outside their purview because portable plug-in electrical equipment was brought into the building by the tenants. Thus, the challenge of controlling plug loads often falls to building managers, who must evaluate various strategies to employ.
Strategies for controlling plug load
As building managers become more adept at managing the energy required for HVAC and lighting, the need to control plug load becomes greater. In the highly efficient home office of IDeAs, plug loads are nearly 50% of total energy use (see figure below).
Is the answer to reducing plug load buying and using better equipment or turning off power? According to Kaneda, the answer is probably both.
More efficient equipment. Today's electrical devices are more efficient than those manufactured just a few years ago. However, in most commercial spaces there are many more electrical devices in use. For example, computers may be marginally more efficient (e.g. watts/calculation), but they are in much wider use than a generation ago. Flat screens are more efficient than CRTs, but people today use larger screens and may have multiple screens at one workstation.
Turning off equipment. It is theoretically possible for individuals to turn off each piece of equipment whenever it is not in use. However, an automated approach is necessary because individuals can't be depended on to consistently turn off equipment. Any automated system must take into account what is most appropriate to turn off. Automatically cutting power to a computer every time the user steps out of the room risks a sudden loss of data. Nor would a manager want to automatically turn off the break room fridge or the aquarium in the reception area every night and weekend.
There are a number of options for controlling plug load by turning off equipment. These include:
· Automated switching using timers and “smart” power strips to power off non-critical equipment and office equipment. Beyond the timing function, these devices provide no power management capability.
· Central power management systems that use software to perform specific tasks, such as enabling sleep settings on all computers on the network.
· Total control systems that provide fully integrated management controls. The Convia® Energy Management System from Legrand/Wiremold is an example of such a system.
The total approach to managing plug load
The Wiremold® Convia system combines modular electrical distribution with sensors and programmable controls, which include a desktop gateway, hubs, relay dimmers, power modules, and other accessories such as sensors and switches – all of which are linked by low voltage cabling. In this way the receptacles, rather than the electrical devices themselves, are managed and controlled. When power modules are linked to electrical receptacles, the circuit's energy usage is also monitored and archived to enhance power management. The Convia system also has the capability to dynamically balance loads based on set priorities, and shed loads on demand.
One of the biggest challenges in reducing plug loads has been the inability to accurately track and account for these loads. The Convia Energy Management System meters actual energy use (as opposed to estimating) at a very granular level. This gives facility managers the information they need to optimize the performance of a space. Occupancy is also tracked and presented along with energy information in an intuitive and easy to read dashboard. In addition to functions like occupancy sensing, timed scheduling, and daylight harvesting, the Convia system provides the depth of knowledge necessary for ongoing energy optimization.
Conclusions
As plug loads evolve into the dominant load of a building, design teams clearly must focus on strategies to reduce this critical area of energy consumption. In fact, for the first time a “green” code (IGCC, in development for the International Code Council) is going to require design teams to address plug loads. This new code will require that buildings include receptacles and electrical outlets that are controlled by occupant sensor or a time switch. In larger and more complex facilities in particular, the Wiremold Convia Energy Management System meets these requirements by offering not only a high level of control but also the ability to monitor and manage plug loads.
According to Kaneda, the experience of developing a Net Zero building for his own business shows that plug load is the obvious target for reduction. "Lighting has been cut so much that there is little more to be done," he notes. "Plug loads proportionally are the worst – but that means they also offer the most potential for savings."
# # #